College or Pro: Best Path in MLB The Show 25?

Should You Choose College or the Big Leagues in MLB The Show 25 Road to the Show?

Unlike earlier iterations of Road to the Show, MLB The Show 25 starts your journey as a high school senior at a pivotal moment. Scouts from top-tier colleges and professional teams are watching closely, but you can only choose one path.

Your journey begins during your final season of high school ball, where every game counts toward your reputation. Whether your team wins or loses the state championship, talent scouts will be watching. Between games, you’ll learn more about your options—especially which colleges and pro teams are interested in you. Your performance on the field and at the MLB Combine plays a major role in shaping your opportunities. Strong stats and solid showings can boost your draft stock and expand your college offers.

After the Combine, you’ll make your commitment: sign with a college or turn pro. Even if you're leaning toward college, a pro team may still draft you. Here’s how the decision breaks down, based on a sample scenario:

If I Go Pro

• Receive a signing bonus of 5 Tokens
• Reduced chance of being fast-tracked to the Major Leagues
• Begin pro career as an 18-year-old

If I Go To College

• Receive all benefits of LSU’s official offer
• Pursue the #1 overall pick in a future MLB Draft
• Begin pro career as a 21-year-old after completing college

Ultimately, this choice comes down to personal preference and playstyle. If you’ve grown tired of grinding through the minors year after year, going to college could be the better option. Being selected as the #1 overall pick is a prestigious milestone, and entering the pros with a more polished skill set makes the experience feel entirely different.

However, college isn’t for everyone. If you enjoy the underdog story and don’t mind starting from the bottom, turning pro early gives you a head start on your big league dreams.

The Escapist opted for college, mainly because the opportunity to chase the #1 overall draft pick was too exciting to pass up. Plus, the game fast-forwards to your third year during a championship run, so you don’t miss out on much time-wise. It's the best of both worlds—you gain valuable experience and enter the pros with elite status.

That’s the breakdown of whether you should go to college or go pro in MLB The Show 25 Road to the Show. For more tips and strategies, check out our guide on the best pitching settings for the game.

MLB The Show 25 is now available in Early Access on PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series X|S.